Projection and Differentiation
In the context of psychological development and interpersonal relationships, projection and differentiation play central roles. A couple once came to me for an astrological consultation. They wanted to know, “Is this the person for me? What is our compatibility?” Both were in their mid-to-late 30s, and each had been married before. Rather than answering their surface-level inquiry — “Is this the person for me?” — I redirected the question inward: “Are you the person for you?”
I know — it might sound strange, but this reframing underscores a foundational dynamic in relationships: the need for intrapsychic integration. At the heart of nearly every relationship struggle is this deeper, often unspoken question. Until we face it honestly, we’re likely to keep repeating the same patterns, regardless of who we’re with.
Your unique astrology, particularly when interpreted through a Jungian lens, offers a framework to help you objectify your experiences with others. The people we feel intensely attracted to often reflect traits or psychological contents that we’ve disowned or are unaware of. We’re drawn to them because they carry parts of us we have yet to fully integrate. As Carl Jung observed, such projections are not random but are constellated by complexes within the unconscious of each person. The strange paradox is this: we may feel both profoundly attracted to and simultaneously repelled by the same person.
When we say we are “in love,” the experience often carries an archetypal quality — a compulsive, almost mythic intensity. We feel a kind of fascination or obsession toward someone — regardless of gender or sexual orientation — which often signals a projection of unconscious contents. There’s a magnetic pull, an almost erotic charge, when we meet someone who can carry a projection of our inner psyche, particularly the Shadow, Anima, or Animus as described by Jung in analytical psychology. These projections are typically marked by what Lévy-Bruhl termed participation mystique, a state where the boundaries between self and other dissolve and we enter into a kind of psychological fusion. No amount of reasoning can talk us out of it; we must live it, feel it, and eventually, see through it.
Eventually, and inevitably (for the sake of our psychological growth), the initial honeymoon phase gives way to polarization. The idealized projection fades. We begin to see each other’s all-too-human flaws. Some major conflict arises, and in that friction, a turning point emerges: a crisis that forces us to differentiate. What we call “falling out of love” is often the dissolution of the idealized projections. This disillusionment — though painful — is crucial. It creates the space for differentiation, the psychological process by which we come to know ourselves as distinct from the other. Without it, we remain in a state of fusion, unable to fully individuate.
To differentiate means to discover who we are as separate individuals.
At first, this realization can be jarring. The infatuation felt so real, so consuming. The other person occupied our thoughts constantly. Yes, in the beginning, it feels like destiny. “I’ve known you forever,” we say. And in a way, that’s true. We have known them before — only not as them, but as lost or disowned aspects of ourselves. They become the carrier of our unintegrated Shadow, our inner feminine or masculine, our longing for wholeness. That’s why it feels so intense, so magnetic, so familiar.
Yet projections are slippery. They feel external, but they originate within. As long as these unconscious forces remain unexamined, we may continue to attract — and repel — the same patterns in different people. The more intensely we idealize or vilify someone, the more likely we are caught in the web of projection. And here’s the difficult truth: we often cannot see or accept our Shadow until we actively dislike it in someone else. This moment of irritation, judgment, or even outright aversion is a clue that a part of our psyche is being externalized. It frequently happens with those closest to us — partners, parents, siblings, friends — where emotional intensity is high and boundaries are porous.
Differentiation requires us to recognize the other person not as an extension of ourselves, but as a whole, separate being — with their own flaws, wounds, and depth. It is through this stage of discomfort and disillusionment that true intimacy can emerge: not from fantasy, but from mutual recognition.
As Edward F. Edinger notes in Anatomy of the Psyche, “To the extent that the opposites remain unconscious and unseparated, one lives in a state of participation mystique, which means that one identifies with one side of a pair of opposites and projects its contrary as an enemy. Space for consciousness to exist appears between the opposites, which means one becomes conscious as one is able to contain and endure the opposites within.”
Carl Jung echoes this in CW: 10: Civilization in Transition, The Undiscovered Self, stating:
“If the same unconscious complex is constellated in two people at the same time, it produces a remarkable emotional effect, a projection, which causes either a mutual attraction or a mutual repulsion.”
The Shadow Inside Us: An Open Enemy
This dynamic of projection is not merely poetic — it’s deeply embedded in ancient astrological wisdom. In traditional astrology, the 7th House is known as the House of Marriage, but also, paradoxically, the House of Open Enemies. Why? Because the one we love most deeply often becomes the one with whom we most profoundly clash. The partner becomes the mirror — and eventually, the mirror becomes too honest.
In some relationships, the energies at play are deeply personal — tied to familiar complexes, childhood wounds, or patterns of behavior we can eventually name and integrate. But other relationships feel as though they come from beyond us, as if some larger current is moving through the connection. This is often the case when the outer planets — Uranus, Neptune, or Pluto — form significant aspects in our natal chart. These transpersonal forces operate far beyond the realm of ego. They don’t just ask us to grow — they insist we transform.
Uranus electrifies the bond, often bringing sudden beginnings — or endings — designed to awaken us. The person we meet may shock us out of our patterns, push us into radical authenticity, or pull the rug out from under our attachments. Neptune dissolves boundaries. It can create a soul-deep yearning, a feeling of spiritual fusion, or a mist of illusion that we only learn to see through over time. Pluto, most intense of all, brings a magnetic, often erotic intensity that activates deep psychic wounds. Control, power, compulsion, and regeneration are all part of the Plutonian dance.
When these planets are active between two people, we’re not just engaging with one another — we’re engaging with something archetypal. We may feel fated, haunted, transcendent, or undone. These relationships don’t usually “fit” conventional models. They often defy logic or timing. But if we approach them with consciousness, they become initiatory: they break us open and set us on the path of individuation.
Let me give you an example — a scenario that is quite common when the outer planets are involved.
With permission and care to preserve anonymity, I’ll share a version of it here — not as a case study, but as a mirror of the journey many of us take when love becomes a crucible for self-revelation.
I once worked with a couple — let’s call them Ginger and Leo — who both had Uranus and Pluto strongly placed in their 7th Houses. From the beginning, their connection was electric, passionate and charged with transformative potential. Ginger embodied the Uranian side: liberation, disruption, the need to break out of old relational molds. Leo, on the other hand, was gripped by the Plutonian urge for control. He responded to Ginger’s unpredictability by withdrawing emotionally, attempting to assert power through detachment. His deepest fear was his inability to trust — a classic Plutonian wound. But in trying to manage that fear through emotional detachment and subtle control, he only reinforced her mistrust. Pluto seeks to possess, to merge so deeply that nothing is left untouched, but his guardedness made her recoil. She couldn’t open up to someone who withheld. So she retreated further into her Uranian defenses: unpredictability, aloofness, rebellion. What he saw as flakiness was really her fear of being engulfed. What she saw as control was really his terror of being left behind.
And so the dynamic became a feedback loop — Uranus resisting enmeshment, Pluto fearing disintegration — each partner unconsciously provoking the very behavior they feared in the other. Neither saw that they were carrying two halves of the same mythic energy: the urge to evolve through the crucible of intimacy, where freedom and depth, if held consciously, could eventually coexist.
As we worked together, what began to emerge was a third possibility — not the collapse of one into the other’s mode, but a shared space where transformation didn’t require rupture and intimacy didn’t mean possession. They began to recognize that both Uranus and Pluto were alive in each of them, and that their relationship wasn’t meant to stabilize in a conventional way. It was a crucible — a space where something entirely new could be born if they could both stay present to the fire.
Healing for Ginger and Leo began when they could recognize that they weren’t enemies, but mirrors. The key was not to eliminate their differences, but to integrate the Uranian and Plutonian energies within themselves. For Ginger, that meant facing the fear beneath her flight — learning that intimacy didn’t have to mean self-erasure. For Leo, it meant surrendering the illusion of control and allowing vulnerability to replace strategy. When both partners could hold space for the other’s truth without collapsing into fear or power games, their relationship became what it was always trying to be: a vessel for transformation. Not freedom from each other, and not power over each other — but evolution through each other.
These kinds of relationships ask everything of us. They break our expectations of what love “should” be. But if both people are willing and can hold the tension — if they can honor the autonomy and the intensity, the freedom and the fusion — they can find themselves on the threshold of a new kind of union. One where the soul leads, not the ego. One where we don’t just fall in love — we wake up in it. But again, it takes two who are willing to communicate authentically and share vulnerably.
The astonishing thing — and what Jung so brilliantly articulated — is that a complex doesn’t “belong” to just one person. It lives in the field between them. Astrology can show you that both partners are caught in the same psychic drama; they’ve simply taken opposing roles. To them it seemed as if Ginger carried the longing, the pursuit, the overt desire for connection and Leo carried the retreat, the withholding, the emotional coolness but if we looked more closely, the truth was this: until both could begin to differentiate, to take back their projections and own the disowned parts, these patterns will continue. Not because either is “wrong,” but because the psyche seeks wholeness through the tension of opposites.
Coming Home to Ourselves
At some point, we each must make the journey inward — not to fix ourselves, but to remember who we are beneath the projections. Love, as it turns out, is not about completing each other, but about accompanying one another as we return to wholeness. The people who stir us most — whether through desire or difficulty — are often those who awaken a part of us we’ve projected, disowned, or feared.
To see through the projection is to step through a veil. It’s disorienting, sometimes painful, but also liberating. We no longer need to chase an illusion or push away what we don’t understand. We begin to recognize that love isn’t about finding the “perfect” partner — it’s about recognizing ourselves through the sacred friction of relationship.
And maybe, just maybe, we stop asking, “Are they the one?” and start asking, “How is this relationship calling me deeper into myself?” This is the true work — not of falling in love, but of rising in love. Of grounding soul in the soil of the everyday. Of honoring the archetypes at play and finding the courage to hold them, not project them.
As Leonard Cohen wrote in Anthem:
“Ring the bells that still can ring / Forget your perfect offering / There is a crack in everything / That’s how the light gets in.”
So let the cracks show. Let the projections fall. Let love become the alchemical fire, the Self, God within us always meant it to be.
An Invitation to the 7th House: The Soul’s Mirror
If something in this piece has awakened a flicker of recognition — if you’ve glimpsed a part of yourself in the mirror of love, or felt the magnetic pull of someone who carries your unlived and unknown parts — then you are already walking the path of the 7th House. This house is not merely about romantic partnership. It’s a sacred vessel for soul-making. It’s where the unconscious becomes visible through the other, where your shadows are illuminated, and where — if you’re willing — you can reclaim the lost facets of your being.
In my six-week In-Person (SW Houston) Workshop or Zoom Webinar, we dive into the deep waters of Jung’s Shadow Work and the archetypes that inhabit or rule your Astrological 7th House. Together, we learn to see these energies not as problems to solve, but as guides leading us home to the Self — the God within, as Jung called the God image.
This is not solitary work. The 7th House teaches us that our healing must be shared. It happens in relationship, in reflection, in the willingness to be seen and to see others. As my teacher says, “I alone must become myself, but I cannot become myself alone.”
If your soul is whispering yes, you’re invited. The journey is real. The timing is sacred. And you don’t have to walk it alone.
“My favorite part about being an Astrologer is helping my clients become aware of the birth chart as a map of their soul which manifests from day 1. As Carl Jung said, “We are not born tabula rasa, (blank slates).” You will understand this completely when you have a consultation. My goal is always to help you forgive the past and let go. You are in charge of living your individuality in a creative way that is life enhancing, instead of repeating endless patterns and feeling victimized by your fate.” — Re
Thank you for subscribing to my substack. Please share with others you feel would benefit.
Call 281-799-2900 to schedule an appointment with Re or visit shadowdance.com for more information.
Rebeca Eigen’s Substack is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.